The absence of what we could never experience
*Onward* and the nostalgia for something we feel is ours, even though we never actually lived it
The question that opens
Can we miss something we never had?
Some absences are easy to explain. They have a name, a voice, a shared history, and a collection of memories to return to. We know what’s missing because it was once there. We can recognize the void by comparing it to what once occupied that space.
But there are other absences that are much harder to talk about. They don’t stem from something we lost after having experienced it, but from something that never even happened. They are conversations we imagined but never had, relationships we built from fragments of other people’s stories, gestures we thought we might have received, trips, advice, arguments, hugs, or everyday moments that only exist in our minds.
And, although it may seem strange, we can also feel nostalgic about all of that.
Because we don’t always just miss what we experienced. Sometimes we miss the life we think we could have lived with someone.
That thing that happens to us
When someone important has been gone too soon, or when they were only with us for too short a time for us to form our own memories, our imagination often fills in the gaps left by the experience. We hear about their life, see photographs, recognize gestures that others tell us resemble theirs, and gradually construct a relationship that, in reality, never had time to truly exist.
It’s not a lie. Nor is it a pointless fantasy. It’s a way of searching for meaning.
We need to know where we come from. We need to imagine what place we would have occupied in that person’s life and what place they would have occupied in ours. That’s why we ask questions, reconstruct events, fill in the silences, and transform small clues into a possible story.
The problem arises when that possibility begins to turn into a debt.
Then we no longer just think about who is gone. We begin to think about all that life should have given us but didn’t. The absence is filled with perfect scenes that never had to face reality: conversations that were always timely, absolute understanding, support in difficult moments, words that would have arrived exactly when we needed them.
What never happened has a strange advantage over what we did experience: it could never disappoint us.
The story that puts him in front of it
Onward builds its story around Ian and Barley, two brothers who grew up without their father. However, that absence doesn’t mean the same thing to them. Barley retains memories; Ian can barely piece his own together through photographs, recordings, and stories he’s heard from others.
For Ian, his father is both a person and a possibility.
That’s why the chance to reconnect with him for a few hours means much more than an extraordinary encounter. Ian wants to experience what it would have been like to be with him. He wants to hear him, talk to him, receive something he feels should have been part of his life. The fantastical adventure is, at its core, an attempt to transform an imagined relationship into a real experience.
And that’s where Onward starts to talk about something much deeper than loss.
It speaks of the desire to recover what we never had.
The mirror
There’s an important difference between missing a person and missing the relationship we imagined we would have had with them. The two can become so intertwined that they’re almost indistinguishable, but they’re not exactly the same thing.
When we remember someone with whom we shared our life, our memories also contain imperfections. There were good times and bad, important conversations and perfectly ordinary days. Memory can idealize, but it has a reality to rely on.
In contrast, when the relationship barely existed, the imagination has much more room to maneuver.
We can build the person we needed.
And that can stay with us for years without us being fully aware of it. Sometimes we expect something from other people that, in reality, belongs to that relationship we were never able to experience. Or we feel that there’s an essential piece of our story that should be there, and that until we manage to recover it somehow, nothing will ever truly fit together.
Onward begins by playing precisely with that expectation. Ian believes the ultimate answer lies at the end of the journey. If he manages to reach it, if he succeeds in completing the magic, if he can finally be with his father, perhaps something within him will find the place it has been searching for all these years.
But the tour slowly introduces another perspective.
As Ian tries to reach the one who was missing, he begins to recognize more clearly the one who was always there.
Barley doesn’t replace his father. That would be too simplistic and also unfair. No one replaces anyone. Every bond occupies a different place. But Barley has accompanied, protected, taught, encouraged, and supported Ian in ways that Ian had long associated with his absent father.
The film does not eliminate the absence.
It does something even more interesting: it changes the place from which we look at it.
And then a question arises that can be uncomfortable even off-screen. How many times have we been so focused on what we lacked that we failed to recognize what we did receive?
What we do with it
Acknowledging what we never experienced doesn’t mean we shouldn’t care. Absences leave legitimate questions and desires that don’t need to be corrected. We may have needed someone. We may wish they had been there. We may even imagine how our story would have changed if circumstances had been different.
Denying it doesn’t make us stronger.
But perhaps we don’t need to spend our whole lives trying to rebuild an impossible relationship.
There comes a time when we can allow ourselves to look at absence without asking it to give back what it never had the chance to give us. And then space opens up for something else: recognizing the unexpected ways in which we were indeed accompanied.
Sometimes they were siblings. Or grandparents. Or a mother who shouldered far more than one person should have. Or a teacher. A friend. A partner. Someone who came into our lives later. People who didn’t replace the one who was gone, but who were there when we needed someone to be.
That doesn’t make up for a loss.
But it broadens our history.
Because our lives are not made up solely of those who should have been there. They are also made up of those who chose to stay.
Perhaps accepting certain absences consists precisely of that: ceasing to ask ourselves only about the life we could not live and beginning to recognize the one that, despite everything, we have lived.
An idea to take us
Sometimes we spend so much time looking at those who are missing that we take too long to recognize all that those who stayed did.
The question that follows
What kind of relationship have you imagined for so long that it may have prevented you from fully recognizing those who were actually there for you?
José María Sánchez Villa
The question continues.
Related
Good Hope
VC Noticias
17 November, 2026
4 min
A Light in Political Endeavor
Exaudi Staff
16 November, 2026
4 min
Leo XIV: “A defenseless child is the answer God gives to humanity plunged into darkness”
Exaudi Staff
14 November, 2026
6 min
Surviving the family group chat without losing your faith: a handbook for digital holiness and patience
Miguel Morales Gabriel
13 November, 2026
3 min
(EN)
(ES)
(IT)
