Refuge or prison: when love begins to demand too much from the other person
An embrace that doesn’t suffocate: moving from emotional dependency to a love that sets free
There are days when you sit at your desk in the newsroom, watch Madrid’s traffic swallow up the morning, and think about how often we mistake thirst for the glass. It happens a lot with dating. We talk about affection, devotion, spending hours on the phone as if our lives depended on it, and suddenly romance stops being a space where we can breathe freely and becomes a small, padded cell. We’ve all been there. We disguise it as movie romance, but scratch the surface and what emerges isn’t freedom, but a tremendous fear of being alone with ourselves.
Let’s take the case of Clara and Marcos. They had only been together for a year and a half when Clara began to feel suffocated. Marcos wasn’t a bad guy, not at all; he had simply made Clara his sole compass, his only weekend plan, and his exclusive source of emotional validation. If she met up with her university friends, her phone would start buzzing with messages laden with a subtle demand for exclusivity. “We’re so happy just the two of us, why do you need to see anyone else?” he would say with a smile that disarmed any guilt. Little by little, Clara stopped going to choir rehearsals, spaced out her calls to her family, and reduced her world to the perimeter of Marcos’s gaze. Until one afternoon, after a pointless argument because she had left work late, she felt a physical suffocation she couldn’t quite put her finger on. It wasn’t love that held them together; it was a scaffold of emotional emergencies where neither dared to let go of the other for fear of falling into the abyss.
That trap—devouring one another while believing it’s a true fusion—is precisely what the priest and theologian José Luis Martín Descalzo so profoundly warned against in his writings on human affection. Christian love, the kind that truly matures, doesn’t seek to quench thirst by absorbing the other, but rather to enlarge their heart. Family therapists often recall this in consultations when they see young couples arrive exhausted from constantly monitoring each other: emotional dependency disguises what is actually an unresolved personal emptiness as devotion. When one partner needs the other to avoid feeling adrift, the relationship ceases to be an encounter of two freedoms and becomes a mutual dependence. They no longer walk side by side; they walk side by side, dragging their feet and measuring each step so as not to ignite the other’s insecurity.
The Church’s spiritual tradition has always had a very clear perspective on this, far removed from cheap sentimentality. Saint Francis de Sales, in his classic * Introduction to the Devout Life *, dedicated wonderful pages to warning about the dangers of possessive affection. He said with his characteristic subtlety that holy love is free, peaceful, and expansive, while disordered attachment is narrow, jealous, and always has a racing pulse. The Savoyard saint insisted that when a relationship becomes suffocating, the soul loses its peace, and God ceases to be the center, becoming a mere bystander before the idol we have made of the other person. It’s not a matter of loving less, but of loving better, allowing fresh air into the relationship and ensuring that each person remains firmly rooted in their own heart.
To discern whether we’re on solid ground or slipping into a subtle dependency, it’s worth pausing to examine the details of daily life. Do we experience the time we spend apart with the tranquility of someone cultivating their own life, or with the anxiety of someone counting down the minutes until we can reconnect? Are we happy to see our partner grow professionally, have their own friends, and pursue independent hobbies, or does the idea of not being indispensable in every aspect of their day make our stomachs churn? These are questions that sting a little when we ask them, but they clear our perspective and bring truth back to a relationship that truly wants to last.
Ultimately, crossing the threshold into a mature relationship requires the kind of courage Saint Augustine spoke of in his Confessions , when he prayed, “Lord, grant that I may know myself and know you.” For only those who know themselves before God can look upon another without devouring them, capable of loving without binding, knowing that true affection is not a chain that keeps us grounded, but rather wings wide open to fly together without losing our way.
To talk and look each other in the eyes
- Do I feel like I need constant approval from my partner to feel safe or valued in my day-to-day life?
- Have I gradually abandoned my personal space, my friendships, or my hobbies since the relationship began?
- How do I react when my partner decides to make plans without me? Am I happy for their independence or do I experience anxiety and anger?
“Love does not consist in gazing at one another, but in looking together in the same direction.” – Saint Augustine
Related
Surviving the family group chat without losing your faith: a handbook for digital holiness and patience
Miguel Morales Gabriel
13 November, 2026
3 min
The Low Volume of Love: Rediscovering Silence to Listen to Our Loved Ones
Laetare
13 November, 2026
3 min
J.H. Newman and that inner light…
María José Calvo
12 November, 2026
7 min
One Destiny. One Bread!
Rosa Montenegro
12 November, 2026
5 min
(EN)
(ES)
(IT)
